The superannuation fund worth considering is one whose investments, costs, insurance and services fit your circumstances, rather than one that simply tops a ranking. Moneysmart’s guidance identifies these features alongside investment performance as the basis for comparison. Most people can choose where their super payments go, although employment arrangements and membership restrictions can limit the available options.
For business owners, high-income professionals and families, the comparison needs to distinguish investment suitability from account features. The framework below helps you assess your current fund against alternatives; the separate rollover checklist covers what to check if changing funds becomes appropriate.
Key takeaways
- Moneysmart recommends comparing similar investment options over the same period, using at least five years of performance.
- Super fees may include dollar amounts, percentage charges or both, so the account balance matters.
- Leaving a fund can mean losing insurance; comparable premiums do not necessarily mean comparable cover.
- The ATO’s YourSuper tool compares MySuper products, not every super product.
| Comparison item | Current fund | Alternative A | Alternative B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product and investment option | Record name | Record name | Record name |
| Investment mix and risk | Record details | Record details | Record details |
| Returns over matching periods | Record period and result | Record period and result | Record period and result |
| Fees at the same balance | Record costs | Record costs | Record costs |
| Insurance terms and premiums | Record separately | Record separately | Record separately |
| Services and additional costs | Record details | Record details | Record details |
| Membership access | Confirm eligibility | Confirm eligibility | Confirm eligibility |
| Evidence | Document title and date | Document title and date | Document title and date |

How Can I Choose a Superannuation Fund Using Fair Comparisons?
A fair superannuation comparison separates the fund from the investment option inside it. Moneysmart explains that funds can offer single-asset investments and diversified options, with different risks. The relevant comparison is between options suited to similar needs, not between fund names or labels alone.
Match investments before comparing performance
An investment option determines how your super is invested. Asset allocation means the mix of investments, such as shares, property and cash. Available options should be assessed against risk tolerance and time to retirement.
Moneysmart recommends comparing similar options over the same period of at least five years. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. A strong result over a shorter period does not answer whether the investment option suits the member.
Growth options generally seek higher returns with greater exposure to shares and can experience larger losses in some years. Balanced options spread investments across assets and aim for moderate returns and risk. Those differences matter before comparing reported results.
The broader superannuation planning guide places fund selection within the wider planning picture. This comparison focuses on the account and investment options, rather than contribution or retirement strategies.
Read more: Superannuation in Australia: A Planning Guide
How Do Fees Compare When I Choose a Superannuation Fund?
Super fees need to be compared at the same account balance because funds may charge fixed dollar amounts, percentages or both. According to Moneysmart, administration and investment fees are only part of the comparison. Transaction costs, advice charges and costs associated with changing investments can also matter.
Use each product disclosure statement, or PDS, to record:
- Administration fees, including intra-fund advice.
- Investment fees and buy/sell spreads, which are costs associated with buying or selling investments.
- Transaction and switching fees.
- Personal advice fees.
Keep insurance premiums separate. Also check how fees affect the returns being compared, rather than assuming every published return uses the same basis.
What does Moneysmart’s fee example demonstrate?
Illustrative example (hypothetical, not a real client): Moneysmart’s published illustration describes a 30-year-old employee earning $50,000 annually with $20,000 in super. It compares fees of 2.5% with 1%, assuming the same investment performance.
The published age-65 balances are $336,000 for the lower-fee fund and $255,000 for the higher-fee fund.
The difference is $336,000 − $255,000 = $81,000.
This subtraction checks the difference between the published balances; it does not reproduce the projection. Moneysmart does not state an income year or the projection assumptions in this illustration. The example is not a likely personal outcome, a projection for the reader or personal advice.
Not sure how this applies to you?
Start with a free Financial Health Check™ — a simple way to see where you stand before any advice is given.
The supported principle is narrower than the headline difference: with the same investment performance, lower fees usually help a balance grow faster. Fees alone do not determine suitability.
For a worked example at two different account balances, see how to compare super fund fees when you’re self-employed.
Fund charges also differ from the cost of personal advice. At Infinite Zephyr, we explain the arrangements for our work on our pricing page; those costs are separate from the product comparison.

Should I Get Superannuation Insurance?
Insurance through super is an option, rather than a reason to choose a fund without examining its other features. Moneysmart’s superannuation guidance explains that members can choose whether to hold cover through super, and premiums are deducted from their balance. The appropriate comparison depends on the cover and its terms.
Funds usually offer life cover, which pays on death; total and permanent disability cover, often called TPD; and income protection. Some provide automatic cover, while other cover requires an application.
Insurance checks before leaving a fund
Record these details separately from investment performance:
- The premium and amount of cover.
- Definitions and exclusions that affect what is covered.
- Waiting periods.
- Automatic cover and additional cover available by application.
- Whether leaving the current fund means losing insurance.
A lower premium is not enough to show that cover is comparable. For business owners and self-employed professionals, occupation deserves attention because it can affect the cost of insurance. The relevant definitions also need comparison rather than an assumption that similarly named policies provide the same cover.
Moneysmart cautions that combining accounts can mean losing insurance a member wants to retain. Comparing cover belongs before an account is closed.
What Can the YourSuper Comparison Tool Tell Me?
The ATO’s YourSuper comparison tool compares MySuper products using performance, fees and other product information. It can support a shortlist, but its scope is narrower than the whole super market. A missing account may be a choice product rather than a MySuper product.
MySuper is a basic super product designed without unnecessary features and fees. A fund can offer both MySuper and other products.
Check the settings and membership status
The non-personalised tool starts with a $50,000 balance. Its filters allow the balance and age to be adjusted, which can change the relevant fee comparison.
The tool compares up to four MySuper products in detail. Its personalised version through myGov also shows existing super accounts alongside other products.
A selectable result is not necessarily open to new members. The ATO states that a MySuper product underperforming for two consecutive years cannot accept new members until it receives a performing rating. Existing members are treated differently.
The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, or APRA, supplies the tool’s data. Its performance-test result describes whether a product met the benchmark; it is not a personal suitability assessment.

When Is a Simple Super Fund Shortlist Insufficient?
A basic shortlist may be insufficient where employment arrangements restrict fund choice, membership is limited or a defined benefit arrangement is involved. The ATO’s fund-choice guidance also distinguishes funds managed for members from self-managed super funds, where members take legal responsibility as trustees.
| Fund type | Membership or responsibility check |
|---|---|
| Industry | Some restrict membership; others are open to everyone |
| Retail | Usually run by financial institutions and open to everyone |
| Public sector | Generally for government employees |
| Corporate | Generally restricted to a particular employer’s employees |
| Self-managed super fund | Members manage the fund and carry trustee responsibilities |
An SMSF is not simply another investment menu. Running one involves investment decisions, compliance work, time and costs; it is not universally preferable to a fund managed for members.
Who this comparison method may not suit
- A MySuper-only search may not suit someone assessing choice products.
- A wider investment menu may be unsuitable for someone unwilling to take greater responsibility for investment decisions.
- A lowest-fee-only decision can overlook insurance differences.
- Defined benefits and employment-based restrictions can make personal advice relevant before a shortlist becomes a decision.
For readers considering that support, our financial advice services provide the context for discussing super alongside broader circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an industry fund better than a retail fund?
The category alone does not determine suitability. Industry funds and retail funds still need comparison on investments, performance, costs, insurance and services, with membership eligibility checked separately.
Can I change investments without changing super funds?
Moneysmart says members can change their investment choice within their fund. Whether the existing fund offers an appropriate alternative depends on its available options; changing the investment option and changing the fund are different decisions.
What happens if I do not choose an investment option?
Moneysmart explains that the fund generally places the money in its MySuper product when no investment choice has been made. MySuper is designed to suit most people, but that does not make it a personal recommendation.
Can I rely on a comparison website’s rating?
Moneysmart cautions against choosing a fund solely on a rating from a comparison website. Websites can cover different products, use different assessment criteria and earn money from promoted links.
Which services are worth comparing?
Compare online tools, access to advice, customer service channels and how easily account changes can be made. Moneysmart notes that additional services may cost more, so the comparison should record both access and price.
Next step
Talk through your retirement plan
We can model how the rules in this guide apply to your situation, across super, investments and your other assets.
Start with a free Financial Health Check™
General information only. Personal advice requires an agreed scope and may need a Statement of Advice (SOA) or Record of Advice (ROA). Fees are agreed in writing before you start.
Sources: Moneysmart — Choosing a super fund; Moneysmart — Superannuation; Australian Taxation Office — YourSuper comparison tool and Choosing a super fund.
Tax, superannuation, and regulatory information in this article is based on legislation and ATO/ASIC guidance current as of 2026. These rules are complex and subject to change, and this article is not updated retrospectively when they do. This information is a general summary only and should not be relied upon as formal tax advice — always confirm current rules with a registered tax agent or the ATO directly.
General Advice Warning: This information is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial, legal, or tax advice. It has been prepared without taking into account your individual objectives, financial situation, or needs. Before acting on any information, you should consider its appropriateness having regard to your objectives, financial situation, and needs, and seek professional advice from a licensed financial adviser and registered tax agent. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
This information is provided by Infinite Zephyr, an Authorised Representative (AR 001268024) of NDT Capital Pty Ltd (AFSL 558899). You can verify this authorisation on the ASIC Financial Advisers Register. For dispute resolution, contact the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA).